April 18, 2024

We’re in a Constitutional Crisis, and Only Voters Can Save Us



The New York Times building on Sept. 6, 2018. (ANGELA WEISS/Agence France-Presse/Getty Images)


Republican officials have made the conscious decision to remain blind, deaf, and mute.


By Eugene Robinson / 09.07.2018
The Washington Post



Journalist Bob Woodwardā€™s new book and an op-ed by an anonymous administration official portray President Trump as dangerously capricious and amoral, exhibiting textbook symptoms of narcissistic personality disorder and behaving in ways that suggest, to some, early signs of age-related dementia.

But you knew that.

Weā€™ve all known about Trump from the beginning. Weā€™ve known that he was entirely unfit to hold any public office, much less wield the awesome powers of the presidency, regardless of what political views he might have. Trump demonstrates this fact every single day.

On Wednesday afternoon, the New York Times published an extraordinary essay headlined, ā€œI Am Part of the Resistance Inside the Trump Administration.ā€ In it, an unnamed ā€œsenior officialā€ claimed to be ā€œworking diligently from within,ā€ in concert with ā€œmanyā€ colleagues, ā€œto frustrate parts of [Trumpā€™s] agenda and his worst inclinations.ā€ The author went on to describe chaos, dysfunction and a president who changes his mind ā€œfrom one minute to the next.ā€

Even more alarming, however, was the response from retiring Sen. Bob Corker (R-Tenn.), one of the few GOP officials who ever dared to criticize Trump, even mildly: ā€œThis is what all of us have understood to be the situation from day one.ā€

Trumpā€™s enablers in Congress have all been lying to us. They pretend there is a normal president in the White House instead of, letā€™s be honest, a maniac. They know the risk the nation is running. They have the power to alleviate that risk, but they do nothing, instead counting on ā€œmature adultsā€ in the administration to keep Trump from plunging the nation off some cliff.

According to Woodwardā€™s book ā€œFear,ā€ Trump was going to pull the United States out of a trade agreement with South Korea, but former top economic adviser Gary Cohn, who saw the move as unthinkable, simply swiped the order from Trumpā€™s desk before he could sign it. At another point, the book reports, Trump phoned Defense Secretary Jim Mattis and commanded him to assassinate Syrian President Bashar al-Assad. According to Woodward, Mattis played along, hung up the phone and told an aide, ā€œWeā€™re not going to do any of that.ā€

It feels as though we have entered a new phase of the Trump saga. As with all the prior phases, itā€™s impossible to predict with confidence what will happen. But the combination of the Woodward book and the insiderā€™s op-ed feels like an inflection point.

We learned about the insanity inside the West Wing months ago from Michael Wolffā€™s ā€œFire and Fury,ā€ but he got enough little things wrong to cast doubt on the big things he reported. We read it all again in Omarosa Manigault Newmanā€™s ā€œUnhinged,ā€ but she was a professional minor celebrity who had only glowing things to say about Trump until she got fired. Woodward, to say the least, is different.

Beginning with Watergate and Deep Throat, Woodward has set the gold standard for Washington-based investigative reporting. He doesnā€™t just get the goods; he keeps meticulous records, including recordings of many of his interviews. You will note that the denials coming from the Trump administration are actually carefully worded non-denials that skirt, rather than confront, the specifics of what Woodward wrote.

His account supports what weā€™ve been told all along by award-winning White House correspondents from The Post, the Times and other media organizations.

As for the anonymous ā€œsenior officialā€ who penned the op-ed in the Times, Iā€™m not inclined to join the chorus of commentators who say he or she is being cowardly and instead should have gone public, resigned in front of television cameras, marched up to Congress and demanded to testify and . . . and then what? Exactly what would such a performance achieve?

Does anyone believe the Republican leadership in the House and Senate would do anything? As Corker said, Trumpā€™s unfitness has been obvious from the beginning. Republican officials have made the conscious decision to see, hear and speak no evil. Weā€™re probably better off with the ā€œsenior officialā€ still in place, saving us from Trumpā€™s destructive whims.

The whistleblower wrote that ā€œthere were early whispers within the cabinet of invoking the 25th Amendmentā€ by which Trump could be removed, but ā€œno one wanted to precipitate a constitutional crisis.ā€

After this week, however, itā€™s clear that weā€™re already in a constitutional crisis of frightening proportions. The Cabinet will not act. Congress, under GOP control, will not act. The internal ā€œresistanceā€ can only do so much.

Voters are the last line of defense. You must save the day.


Published by Common Dreams under the terms of a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 license.