Car shipping gets more complicated once the vehicle, route, and delivery method change.
Shipping a family sedan from one city to another within the US is one task. An enclosed move for a classic-car, an RV shipment, or an international car move can require another.
A-1 Auto Transport is our overall strongest starting point for buyers looking for broad vehicle and route flexibility. Currently, they provide services for everything from your everyday cars and trucks to motorcycles, boats, RVs, ATVs, specialty vehicles and heavy equipment, both domestically and overseas.
The options below may make sense if your primary concern is more specific, like relocation support, price protection or broker services.
What We Cover
- Quick comparison
- A-1 Auto Transport
- Montway Auto Transport
- Sherpa Auto Transport
- AmeriFreight Auto Transport
- What to check before booking
- Final verdict
Quick Comparison
| Company | Best for | Route scope | Notable transport options |
| A-1 Auto Transport | Delivers comprehensive vehicle transportation options for broad vehicle and route needs | Wide Variety of Vehicles; Nationwide and International Shipping | Open or Enclosed; Door-To-Door; Specialty Transport; Oversized Vehicles |
| Montway Auto Transport | Moving-related transport | United States and port pickups for international | Open/enclosed/express door-to-door shipping |
| Sherpa Auto Transport | Quote predictability | Nationwide shipping. Alaska, Hawaii and International transport available. | Open, Enclosed, Expedited and Door-to-Door shipping |
| AmeriFreight Auto Transport | Broker consultation | Across the U.S. | Open, enclosed, expedited, door-to-door shipment |
1. A-1 Auto Transport: Best Overall for Broad Vehicle and Route Needs
A-1 Auto Transport has the broadest vehicle mix of the four companies compared here.
Its existing service pages include regular cars and SUVs as well as motorcycles, boats, RVs/ATVs, classic and exotic vehicles, and heavy machinery. Nationwide and international shipping are also displayed.
That matters when the shipment is not completely ordinary.
An open transport may be what you’re looking for if your family is moving a sedan cross country. A collector might want enclosed shipping. If you’re transporting an RV, boat, or ATV you will need a carrier that can accommodate a bigger or unusual vehicle.
The biggest benefit that A-1 Auto Transport can offer buyers who are comparing customized auto transport services is that the method of transport can be better tailored to accommodate a wider range of vehicle types and routes within one carrier network.
Useful options include:
- Domestic shipping: Vehicle transport is available across all 50 states.
- International shipping: Overseas transport is available for cars and other vehicle types.
- Open and enclosed carriers: Customers can select either standard open haulage or additional enclosure if a vehicle requires more protection.
- Specialized vehicle transport: Services offered include motorcycles, RVs, boats, ATVs, classic cars, heavy equipment (published).
- Door-to-door service: Pickup and delivery available close to requested addresses if truck access/local regulations permit.
The company has its own BBB customer review page. There are some recent reviews praising their communication and delivery. It is helpful as another voice of customers to cross-check rather than reassurance of how any one shipment will go.
Best for: buyers looking for versatility between standard vehicles, specialty cars, heavy-duty trucks or international shipping.
2. Montway Auto Transport: Best for Relocation-Focused Shipping
Montway Auto Transport is a good fit when transporting a vehicle as part of a household or business relocation.
Their relocation service now focuses on coordinated vehicle moves, communication, and a network of carriers across the country. Montway Auto Transport provides open, enclosed, expedited and door-to-door shipping for consumers as well.
Montway Auto Transport lists foreign relocation as something it offers, but the international page of its website currently reads that it is not an international auto transportation company. They handle the US transportation leg to and from ports and partner with international carriers.
Why does that matter?
An international moving buyer needs to know where the door-to-door auto transport coverage leaves off and where the ocean or air carrier’s responsibility begins. If you are moving within the U.S. it’s much simpler: Your assigned trucker drives as close to your pick-up and delivery locations as is safely and legally possible.
Pickup/delivery and communication are often topics mentioned in recent BBB reviews. This may differ depending on your route and carrier.
Best for: Buyers who are moving their car as part of a larger life transition and prioritize a streamlined relocation process.
3. Sherpa Auto Transport: Best for Quote Predictability
Sherpa Auto Transport puts unusual emphasis on the quoted total.
Its Price Lock Promise® states that the price quoted for shipment to the customer is a firm price. If the originally quoted amount proves insufficient to secure a reputable carrier, Sherpa Auto Transport will apply up to $300 of its own money from the initial payment instead of raising the customer’s total.
That makes the distinction easy to understand.
Sherpa Auto Transport is probably the best option of these for buyers who value quote stability highly.
The company provides door-to-door service across the country, open and enclosed transportation, express services, Alaska and Hawaii transportation, and overseas auto transport. They partner with carriers and match your shipment with a carrier from its network.
BBB customer reviews from 2026 repeatedly mention communication and pricing, while also showing that individual shipment experiences can differ.
Best for: buyers who prefer a managed broker process with defined price protection.
4. AmeriFreight Auto Transport: Best for Broker Guidance
AmeriFreight Auto Transport suits buyers who want an agent involved in the carrier-selection process.
According to the company’s current website, customers do not enter payment information until later and can see the carrier offer, including pickup and delivery dates and the final cost to ship, before agreeing to accept the service. Services include open, enclosed, expedited and door-to-door transportation.
Recent BBB reviews repeatedly mention individual agents, communication, and help navigating the process.
This agent-led model is primarily why AmeriFreight Auto Transport makes the cut. This model may be helpful if you are a first time shipper and would like someone to help explain carrier options to you instead of navigating the marketplace yourself.
Here’s some extra category knowledge, according to ConsumerAffairs’ existing auto shipping comparison, reviews of these companies indicate that experiences can differ greatly from shipment to shipment, even when it comes to issues such as timing, communication and fees.
Best suited to: buyers who value hands-on broker assistance before a carrier is booked.
What to Check Before Booking an Auto Transport Company
Price matters, but it is only one part of choosing auto transport services.
Start with these checks:
- Broker or carrier: Are they brokering someone else to move your vehicle or will they be driving the truck themselves?
- Federal authority: Interstate brokers require FMCSA broker authority. Refer to FMCSA broker registration guidance for information on the federal process.
- Open versus enclosed transport: Open transport is the most affordable option, but there are occasions where enclosed transport makes sense (additional protection is desired).
- Pickup access: Door-to-door service might involve meeting at a location close to your address if the truck cannot legally or safely drive to your exact location.
- Timing: What dates are estimated, is any pickup or delivery commitment firm?
- Condition documentation: how will the condition of the vehicle be documented at pick up and delivery?
The key question is simple: does the provider fit the actual shipment?
A standard sedan, enclosed classic car, RV, and overseas vehicle move are all examples of auto shipping. However they don’t all have the same shipping needs.
Final Verdict
Each company has a credible use case.
Montway Auto Transport is a strong comparison for relocation-focused moves. Sherpa Auto Transport stands out for its price-protection policy. AmeriFreight Auto Transport may suit buyers who want more agent involvement.
A-1 Auto Transport comes out ahead as the overall winner of this comparison if versatility is your tie-breaker.
A-1 Auto Transport offers extensive reach nationwide and into Canada and Mexico.
About the Author
