Filling for an intervention order in Victoria can have significant impacts on your housing, work and reputation. You need a strategic legal response whether the charges have been issued by the police or a family member. You can make informed decisions from the outset if you have a clear idea of how your lawyer will tackle the process.
A seasoned intervention order lawyer is essential in safeguarding your rights all the time. From the initial mention hearing to a contested hearing, your lawyer will consider the allegations, inform you of the options available and work to achieve the best possible outcome. Under Victorian law, this is the usual answer to that.
Initial Assessment and the Mention Hearing
When an application is made, the matter is initially set down for a mention hearing in the Magistrates’ Court. Your lawyer is present at this hearing to represent you and to ascertain the nature of the allegations.
If there is already an interim order in place, your lawyer may be able to argue for immediate changes to the terms. This can include access to the premises to retrieve key items or modifying exclusion areas so your work does not suffer.
Your lawyer also recommends a course of action at this point. The options are to consent to the order, to negotiate an undertaking or to oppose the application in its entirety. The best approach will depend on the strength of the evidence and how it may impact your situation.
Requesting Further and Better Particulars
Sometimes allegations in an intervention order application are vague and do not contain specific dates, times or locations. In this case, your lawyer files a formal application for Further and Better Particulars from the applicant.
The practice under the Magistrates’ Court is that the applicant must particularise the alleged incidents before the matter can proceed. If either party requests further information, a magistrate can order these further particulars, the Magistrates’ Court of Victoria says. This step is designed to avoid surprise evidence at a hearing and to allow the defence adequate time to prepare.
Negotiating a Consent Without Admission
One of the most common strategies is to negotiate a resolution where you agree to the intervention order being made but do not admit to the allegations against you. This is called a no-admission consent.
The main advantage of this approach is that you agree to the terms of the order without formally admitting that family violence occurred. Intervention orders are civil, not criminal matters, so consenting without admission means the allegations do not go on a criminal record.
This route is often recommended when the order’s stipulations are tolerable and requesting a contested hearing would impose disproportionate stress and time and legal cost.
Contesting the Application at a Hearing
If the allegations are false or grossly exaggerated or if the proposed conditions are unworkable, your lawyer will be making preparations to oppose the application at a formal hearing. This includes several stages:
- Directions hearing: Making time limits for the presentation of witness statements, evidence and supporting documents.
- Cross-examination: Your attorney cross-examines the applicant(s) as well as the protected witnesses to uncover inconsistencies or credibility issues. Under the Victorian Rules of Evidence, protected persons are not able to be cross-examined by the respondent. When the respondent is not represented, the magistrate shall make arrangements to have Victoria Legal Aid represent the respondent for this purpose.
- Closing arguments: Your attorney will be making closing arguments at the end of the hearing regarding the need for the order and the feasibility of the conditions.
The magistrate then determines on the balance of probabilities whether family violence has occurred and is likely to occur again. The result is either a dismissal of the application or a final intervention order being made.
Why Legal Representation Matters
You may agree to conditions that will have a major impact on your daily life in your response to an intervention order, or you may not challenge allegations that do not have enough evidence to support them. A lawyer will ensure your response is considered, tactical and consistent with your rights under Victorian law.
Having a lawyer on your side from the start puts you in the best possible position to protect your interests and your future, whether the best way forward is through negotiation, a change of conditions or a fully defended hearing.
About the Author
